Skip to content
London Reel World

Why the John Bolton Case Stands Apart Significantly from Other Former President Critics

Ex security advisor John Bolton appears at the courthouse
Ex security advisor John Bolton appears at the courthouse on recently.

Former President Donald Trump has consistently shown his desire to see critics probed, applying pressure on the Justice Department to prosecute ex FBI Director James Comey and New York Attorney General Letitia James.

"We can't delay any longer, it's killing our standing and credibility," the president stated recently in a Truth Social post.

"They impeached me, and indicted me (5 times!)" he said, referencing the four criminal cases he encountered after departing the White House in 2021 and James's civil case.

Each have subsequently been charged, in situations that numerous specialists have stated appear to be politically motivated and challenging to win in court.

But the latest charges against a presidential opponent, former national security adviser John Bolton, stand apart, legal specialists and former prosecutors say.

"I would say, comparing Bolton's case to James' is like comparing two different things," said Mark Lesko, a former acting US attorney for the Eastern District of New York.

This Details of the Legal Situation

Bolton has been criminally indicted on federal charges related to the alleged improper handling of classified information. After departing the White House in 2019, he has become a vocal Trump critic, going so far as to call him "remarkably ignorant" and unfit for office in his memoir.

Experts contend that while there may be political motivations to target Bolton, the procedures used to obtain an charge and the proof compiled against him indicate a possibly more substantial case than the Justice Department brought against Comey.

"This misconduct that's being claimed is both more serious and appears to have occurred over a significant period of time," commented Carissa Byrne Hessick, a professor at the University of North Carolina School of Law.

During his tenure as Trump's security advisor, and after his 2019 White House exit, prosecutors claimed that Bolton put the nation at risk by improperly retaining and sending sensitive documents to family members using unprotected methods, including AOL. Some of the materials were labeled top secret.

The charge alleges that at one point a hacker accessed to Bolton's account where files were stored and sent an seeming warning to cause "the biggest controversy since Hillary [Clinton]'s emails were leaked".

Bolton pleaded not guilty during a court appearance on Friday to eighteen distinct charges of mishandling sensitive materials.

Retribution or a Strong Legal Argument?

The timing of his charge - arriving on the heels of charges against James - has revived concerns about external influence on the legal system.

Trump previously suggested Bolton belonged in jail, and called him a "sleazebag". Bolton, for his part, wrote a book about his experience in the Trump government that was sharply negative of the leader.

"There's no question that the schedule of this indictment, when combined with others, has prompted questions about the validity of these charges, and the reason these charges are being filed now," said Jamil Jaffer, founder and executive director of the National Security Institute.

However, he added, "if the DOJ is able to demonstrate the allegations stated and show the information is correctly designated, his behavior may certainly have violated the statute".

Charging such a senior official for improperly handling sensitive materials is "uncommon" but not unprecedented, noted Carrie Cordero, a senior fellow at the Center for a New American Security.

"Situations that concern classified information pose difficulties to try, but they may and are filed against equally junior and high-level officials, from occasionally," she said.

Similarities to Examinations into Trump and President

Trump similarly encountered allegations of improperly keeping classified documents at his Mar-a-Lago property in Florida and hindering their return, but that matter was eventually dismissed by a court official and negated by his re-election as leader.

A special counsel also determined that former President Joe Biden wrongfully stored sensitive materials from his time as second-in-command, but failed to criminally charge him.

Bolton's situation bears similarities to Trump's sensitive materials issues, said Mr Lesko, who previously held a senior security role at the Justice Department.

Strict procedures regulate the handling of sensitive materials. To secure a conviction, the government must demonstrate that Bolton knew the information he was sending was classified, and he had to intentionally transmit it to someone not entitled to receive it.

"Due to the classified character of the material at question in this matter, we lack a great deal of details about the reasons the prosecution contends elements like the personal notes and the additional information he shared by electronic message, and why there were classified," said Mr Jaffer.

A More Traditional Legal Action

The procedure by which the DOJ initiated this case will be under scrutiny, following Trump openly posted his desire to see his critics charged and several of those charges came to fruition.

But Mr Lesko said in Bolton's situation, authorities appear to have followed protocol.

"This Bolton prosecution and ultimately the charge seemed to have observed the regular procedure including the rules and norms within the DOJ," he stated.

In contrast to Comey's short, two-page charge, Bolton's was a more "traditional" filing that "explicitly outlines the details involving the circumstances and situation in this instance," Mr Lesko commented.

"It appears fairly aligned with a series of precedents... where government officials mishandled and shared classified material."

NA
About the author

Nathan Alexander

A London-based journalist and storyteller with a passion for uncovering the city's secret narratives and sharing them with the world.

London Reel World

Type to search articles.